| Player | Pos. | School | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Gerald McCoy* | DT | Oklahoma | 98 |
| 2. Ndamukong Suh | DT | Nebraska | 97 |
| 3. Eric Berry* | S | Tennessee | 97 |
| 4. Jason Pierre-Paul | DE | South Florida | 97 |
| 5. Anthony Davis* | OT | Rutgers | 97 |
| 6. Joe Haden* | CB | Florida | 96 |
| 7. Russell Okung | OT | Oklahoma State | 96 |
| 8. Derrick Morgan* | DE | Georgia Tech | 96 |
| 9. Sam Bradford* | QB | Oklahoma | 95 |
| 10. Dez Bryant* | WR | Oklahoma State | 95 |
| 11. C.J. Spiller | RB | Clemson | 95 |
| 12. Bryan Bulaga* | OT | Iowa | 95 |
| 13. Rolando McClain* | ILB | Alabama | 95 |
| 14. Mike Iupati | G | Idaho | 94 |
| 15. Earl Thomas* | S | Texas | 94 |
| 16. Trent Williams | OT | Oklahoma | 94 |
| 17. Brian Price* | DT | UCLA | 94 |
| 18. Brandon Graham | OLB | Michigan | 94 |
| 19. Carlos Dunlap* | DE | Florida | 94 |
| 20. Dan Williams | DT | Tennessee | 93 |
| 21. Sergio Kindle | OLB | Texas | 93 |
| 22. Kyle Wilson | CB | Boise State | 93 |
| 23. Jermaine Gresham | TE | Oklahoma | 93 |
| 24. Everson Griffen* | DE | USC | 92 |
| 25. Taylor Mays | S | USC | 92 |
| 26. Maurkice Pouncey* | C | Florida | 92 |
| 27. Arrelious Benn | WR | Illinois | 92 |
| 28. Jared Odrick | DT | Penn State | 91 |
| 29. Kareem Jackson* | CB | Alabama | 91 |
| 30. Bruce Campbell* | OT | Maryland | 91 |
| 31. Devin McCourty | CB | Rutgers | 90 |
| 32. Ryan Mathews* | RB | Fresno State | 90 |